One of the first questions I hear from homeowners who are thinking about selling is:
“Should I make repairs before I put my house on the market?”
And my answer is almost always the same:
Maybe. But let's not spend a dollar until we know why we're spending it.
This is where having the right real estate agent matters.
Because preparing a home for sale isn't about making it perfect. It's about making smart decisions that help the home compete in today's market.
I've walked through plenty of homes where sellers were ready to spend thousands of dollars fixing things that buyers probably wouldn't have cared about.
I've also walked through homes where a relatively small repair would have made a huge difference in how buyers perceived the property.
The challenge is knowing the difference.
And that's exactly what your real estate agent should help you figure out before you call the contractor, order the new countertops, or spend your weekend painting every room in the house.
The Biggest Mistake Sellers Make
When you've lived in your house for years, it's easy to see everything that's wrong with it.
You notice the carpet you've been meaning to replace.
You notice the outdated light fixtures.
You notice the kitchen that hasn't changed since you moved in.
You notice the bathroom vanity you don't like anymore.
And suddenly you're looking at a $30,000 renovation project.
But here's the problem:
You aren't necessarily selling the house to yourself.
You're selling it to today's buyer.
And today's buyer may not care about the same things you care about.
A perfectly functional kitchen with 1990s cabinets may not require a $40,000 renovation. A dated bathroom may simply need to be clean, bright and functional. That old carpet may not need to be replaced if it is in decent condition.
On the other hand, a leaking roof, water intrusion, broken furnace or obvious safety issue can create much bigger problems.
That's why I don't believe in giving every seller the same checklist.
Every house is different.
Every neighborhood is different.
And every price range has different buyer expectations.
Not Every Repair Is Worth Making
When I'm helping a seller decide what to do before listing, I like to put potential projects into three categories:
1. Fix It
These are the issues that can create legitimate problems during the sale.
Think about things like:
Active water leaks
Significant water intrusion
Major electrical problems
Broken heating or cooling systems
Obvious safety concerns
Structural problems
Damaged roofing
Major plumbing problems
Anything that could create a significant inspection or financing concern
These aren't necessarily cosmetic improvements.
They're about reducing risk.
And in Wisconsin, condition and disclosure are important parts of the selling process. Sellers generally disclose known conditions that adversely affect the property, and Wisconsin REALTORS® Association guidance specifically notes that a listing broker should understand the property's condition and help the seller consider whether certain repairs should be addressed before marketing the property.
That's another reason I want to have this conversation before we put the house on the market.
2. Consider It
This is where things get more interesting.
Maybe the carpet is worn but not terrible.
Maybe the walls need paint.
Maybe the landscaping could use some attention.
Maybe there are a dozen little things around the house that you've stopped noticing because you've lived with them for years.
These improvements can sometimes make a meaningful difference in how a buyer experiences the home.
And they don't necessarily have to be expensive.
A fresh coat of paint.
New cabinet hardware.
Replacing a few dated light fixtures.
Repairing damaged trim.
Cleaning up the landscaping.
Fixing a door that doesn't close properly.
Deep cleaning the house.
Decluttering.
Those things can change the way buyers perceive the property without requiring a massive renovation budget.
3. Don't Waste Your Money
This is probably my favorite category.
Because sometimes the best advice an agent can give you is:
“Don't do that.”
Imagine you're thinking about spending $25,000 updating a kitchen.
Before you do it, I'd want to know:
What are similar homes selling for?
What are competing homes offering?
What price range are we targeting?
What do buyers in this neighborhood expect?
Is the existing kitchen functional?
Will the renovation actually change the home's market position?
How quickly can the work be completed?
What happens if the renovation costs more than expected?
Would buyers prefer to choose their own finishes?
Just because an improvement makes the house nicer doesn't mean it makes financial sense.
That's a distinction sellers need to understand.
Better isn't always more valuable.
The $20,000 Repair That Doesn't Make You $20,000
Here's a mistake I see homeowners make all the time.
They assume:
“If I spend $20,000 improving the house, I'll get $20,000 more when I sell.”
Real estate doesn't work that way.
A renovation can improve marketability without adding an equivalent amount of market value.
Maybe the $20,000 renovation helps the house sell faster.
Maybe it helps you compete against another property.
Maybe it prevents buyers from discounting the home.
Or maybe it makes almost no difference because the buyers who are looking in your price range don't care.
That's why I don't start the conversation with:
“What should we renovate?”
I start with:
“What are we trying to accomplish?”
Those are two very different conversations.
Sometimes You Don't Need to Make the Repair
There's another option sellers sometimes overlook:
Don't fix it. Address it strategically.
Depending on the situation, that might mean:
Pricing the home appropriately
Offering a buyer credit
Providing documentation or estimates
Selling the property in its current condition
Making a smaller repair rather than a complete replacement
For example, let's say your roof is older but still functioning.
Should you automatically spend $15,000 or $20,000 replacing it?
Not necessarily.
We need to look at the age and condition of the roof, comparable properties, buyer expectations, financing considerations and how the issue affects the overall pricing strategy.
Maybe replacing it makes sense.
Maybe it doesn't.
The point is that we should know before spending the money.
What Buyers Are Really Thinking
Put yourself in the buyer's shoes for a minute.
You're walking into a house.
You see a dated kitchen.
Your first thought probably isn't:
“I wonder what this kitchen looked like when the seller bought the house?”
You're thinking:
“How much is this going to cost me?”
That's the real issue.
Buyers don't necessarily need everything to be new.
They need to understand the cost, effort and risk associated with making the home their own.
A house that needs $5,000 of cosmetic work may be completely acceptable.
A house that appears to need $50,000 of unknown work can feel very different.
Uncertainty is expensive.
That's why sometimes a $500 repair can be more valuable than a $10,000 renovation.
Your House Has to Make Sense Compared With the Competition
This is where pricing becomes incredibly important.
Your home isn't being judged in a vacuum.
Buyers are comparing it with everything else they can buy with their money.
If another house down the street is completely updated and yours isn't, you can't simply say:
“But mine is a great house.”
It may be.
But the buyer is asking:
“Which house gives me the best combination of price, condition, location and features?”
That's why a good comparative market analysis should go beyond pulling three or four recent sales and saying, “Here's your price.”
Your agent should be looking at:
Recent comparable sales
Current competition
Pending properties
Days on market
Price reductions
Condition
Updates
Location
Features
Buyer expectations
How your home will compare when buyers are actually shopping
The goal isn't to make your house the nicest house available.
The goal is to make your house compelling at its price.
The Four Things I Look At Before Listing
When a seller asks me what they should do before listing, I generally come back to four things:
Price
What is the market telling us the home is worth in its current condition?
Condition
Are there repairs that could create buyer objections, inspection issues or unnecessary negotiation?
Presentation
Does the house show as well as it possibly can without overspending?
Exposure
Once we put it on the market, are we doing enough to get the property in front of the right buyers?
Because you can have a beautiful house that doesn't sell.
You can have a great house that doesn't sell.
You can even have a house that is priced correctly and still struggle if buyers don't see it.
All four pieces have to work together.
What Should You Ask a Real Estate Agent Before Hiring Them?
This is actually one of the best ways to evaluate a listing agent.
Don't just ask:
“What will you list my house for?”
Ask them:
“If this were your house, what would you fix?”
That's a much better question.
Then ask:
“What would you NOT fix?”
That answer can be just as important.
Ask:
“Which improvements do you believe will actually affect the sale?”
And:
“What are buyers going to compare my house against?”
You can also ask:
“Can you show me examples of homes you've sold that had similar condition issues?”
You're looking for an agent who can explain why they are recommending something.
Not someone who simply hands you a 20-item honey-do list.
A Good Listing Agent Should Save You Money, Too
There's a misconception that a listing agent's job is primarily to get the house listed.
I think that's too small a definition of the job.
A good listing agent should help you make better decisions.
That includes knowing when to spend money.
But it also includes knowing when not to spend money.
If I'm telling a seller to spend $15,000 before listing, I should be able to explain what we're trying to accomplish.
If I'm telling them not to spend $15,000, I should be able to explain that too.
Because your money is not Monopoly money.
It's your equity.
And every dollar you spend preparing the house is a dollar that should have a reason behind it.
Don't Renovate Your Way Into a Smaller Profit
Here's something else to consider.
Every project has more than just a material cost.
There's also:
Your time
Contractor availability
Delays
Change orders
Permits when applicable
Unexpected problems
Carrying costs
Your time spent managing the project
The possibility that the market changes while you're renovating
I've seen sellers delay putting their house on the market for months because they wanted to complete “just one more project.”
Then another project appeared.
Then another.
Eventually, they have a beautifully improved house—but they've spent substantially more than they originally planned and lost valuable time.
Sometimes the best renovation is the one you never start.
The Pre-Listing Walkthrough Should Be a Strategy Session
Before you list, your agent should walk through the property with you and look at it differently than you do as the homeowner.
Not through the eyes of an inspector.
Not through the eyes of a contractor.
And not through the eyes of someone trying to make the house perfect.
Through the eyes of a buyer.
What will they notice first?
What questions will they have?
What could distract them?
What will make them say, “Wow”?
What could make them start subtracting dollars from their offer?
And what simply doesn't matter?
That's the conversation I want sellers to have.
So, Should You Make Repairs Before Listing?
Sometimes. Sometimes not.
The answer depends on the property, the neighborhood, the competition, the price point, the condition of the home and the goals of the seller.
And that's exactly why I wouldn't recommend starting with a contractor.
Start with a strategy.
Before spending $10,000 on a kitchen.
Before replacing every floor.
Before remodeling the bathroom.
Before replacing a roof.
Before painting the entire house.
Talk with an experienced real estate agent and determine what actually needs to happen.
Then spend your money where it has the greatest potential to improve your position in the market.
Because the goal isn't to have the most updated house on the block.
The goal isn't to make your house perfect.
And the goal certainly isn't to spend the most money getting ready to sell.
The goal is to sell your home strategically.
The right real estate agent should be able to help you separate the must-fix items from the nice-to-have items—and the items that simply aren't worth your money.
And sometimes, the most valuable advice your agent can give you isn't:
“Here's what you should fix.”
It's:
“Don't spend the money. Here's what I'd do instead.”
That's the kind of advice you should expect before putting a For Sale sign in the yard.
Ready to take the next step? Reach out to the Reliance Real Estate Team today!
414-659-6965 / [email protected]
If you’d rather listen instead of read, check me out on Spotify:
🎧 Listen on Spotify or Listen on Apple Podcast
Perfect for your commute, workout, or coffee break!
#RealEstateTips #PodcastLife #HomeSellingAdvice #HomeBuyingTips #RealtorLife #WisconsinRealEstate #MilwaukeeRealEstate #WaukeshaCounty
Check out this article next
